When Creating More Is a Workaround
What report proliferation taught me about discovery, confidence, and reuse.
Creating a new report can mean someone needs a new answer. It can also mean they cannot find an answer they already have.
In reporting research at athenahealth, we found that users sometimes created ad-hoc reports for recurring needs because existing content was hard to find or understand. A report name alone did not tell them whether it would answer their question.
Look at what happened before creation
The finding shifted my attention from search alone to discovery, confidence, and reuse. It also suggested a loop worth investigating: difficult retrieval encourages duplication, and a larger collection creates more retrieval work.
This was a qualitative insight from the broader research program, not a measured rate of unnecessary creation. Some users genuinely needed new fields, filters, or answers. Making creation harder would penalize those needs.
Make reuse a credible option
The Report Library direction added clearer descriptions and configuration, organization, quick access, scheduling, and housekeeping.
Favorites exposed the same problem at a smaller scale: a large saved collection could become difficult to navigate. I contributed a limited pinning model for frequently used reports, giving quick access a distinct purpose alongside the broader collection.
The direction went through RITE usability testing, MVP prioritization, and engineering handoff. It was being deployed for launch when I left, so I cannot claim a reduction in duplication or faster production retrieval.
Three questions before adding more creation features
- Did the user look for existing content first? Where did that attempt break down?
- Could they find a report but remain unsure what it contained?
- Does the task require a new answer, or a better route to an existing one?
Creation activity is a signal to investigate. Understanding the preceding task tells you whether to improve creation, discovery, or both.
Related: Report Library case study.